A historic church, school house, rectory and convent, reborn as Hotel Peter and Paul.
Hotel Peter and Paul is the result of a four-year restoration of the former Sts. Peter and Paul Catholic church and school. The site is steeped in history, from the splendid Henry Howard-designed buildings to the school’s appearance in A Confederacy of Dunces, and its author’s (possibly apocryphal) three-person funeral in the church.
The former school house, rectory, church and convent have each been carefully restored and repurposed for new congregants. Each building has its own inspiration and narrative, with the resulting restoration ensuring that no two guest rooms are exactly alike. We hope you will honor this landmark by adding to its history through your own experiences.
The School
House
LET
RESTING GUESTS
LIE
School House Petite
Compact, but well appointed for solo travelers or an economizing pair. Rooms may have a full or queen bed. All rooms have private bathrooms with hand-painted striped tile showers and are decorated with an assortment of antique and bespoke furniture and lighting. All Petites include flat-screen televisions, complimentary wifi, custom Italian linens, air conditioning and toiletries made exclusively for Hotel Peter and Paul.
School House Classic
Built for a pair of lovers or a swish soloist, these commodious chambers feature a queen or king bed and an assortment of antique and bespoke furniture and lighting. All Classics have private bathrooms with hand-painted striped tile showers, flat-screen televisions, complimentary wifi, custom Italian linens, air conditioning and toiletries made exclusively for Hotel Peter and Paul.
School House Classic rooms are available with accessibility features. Please select the 'ADA' option when booking.
School House Grande Loft
For a roomier sojourn, the Grande is fit for nobility. The Grande feature either a queen or king bed in an upstairs sleeping mezzanine, so please let us know if stairs pose a problem for you. All Grande Lofts have private bathrooms with hand-painted striped tile showers and are decorated with an assortment of antique and bespoke furniture and lighting. All rooms include flat-screen televisions, complimentary wifi, custom Italian linens, air conditioning and toiletries made exclusively for Hotel Peter and Paul.
School House Bunk
Cozy quarters with a bunk containing two twin beds, fit for you and a companion. Can be rented on its own or alongside an adjoining School House Classic with king bed. Features a private bathroom with hand-painted striped tile showers and is decorated with an assortment of antique and bespoke furniture and lighting. The Bunk includes flat-screen television, complimentary wifi, custom Italian linens, air conditioning and toiletries made exclusively for Hotel Peter and Paul.
School House Two of Queens
Designed for pyjama parties and ghost stories, the Two of Queens sleeps up to four guests in two plush queen beds. Our Two of Queens feature either two Queens side by side or one in an an upstairs sleeping mezzanine and one downstairs – so please let us know if stairs pose a problem for you. All Two of Queens have private bathrooms with hand-painted striped tile showers and are decorated with an assortment of antique and bespoke furniture and lighting. All Two of Queens include flat-screen televisions, complimentary wifi, custom Italian linens, air conditioning and toiletries made exclusively for Hotel Peter and Paul.
The Rectory
FORTUNE FAVORS
THE CURIOUS
Rectory Classic
The four rarified Rectory Classic Rooms each boast canopied queen beds, sumptuous marble bathrooms and are decorated with an assortment of antique and bespoke furniture and lighting. Their dramatic furnishings are perfectly suited for a curious traveler who's seeking a lively stay as they are centered over the courtyard and in the center of things. All rooms include flat-screen televisions, complimentary wifi, custom Italian linens, air conditioning and toiletries made exclusively for Hotel Peter and Paul.
The Rector's Repose
Closest to heaven, this room features a king bed flanking floor-to-ceiling slip-head windows and a custom limestone bathtub outside the bathroom. Perched atop the Rectory, this room is ideal for languid night-time baths and slow, bright mornings. It features a flat-screen television, complimentary wifi, custom Italian linens, air conditioning and toiletries made exclusively for Hotel Peter and Paul.
The Convent
EXCHANGE
THE NORTHERN STAR
FOR SERENDIPITY
Convent Classic
All five Convent Classic rooms have sweetly canopied queen or king beds, large and serene bathrooms and are decorated with an assortment of antique and bespoke furniture and lighting. All rooms include flat-screen televisions, complimentary wifi, custom Italian linens, air conditioning and toiletries made exclusively for Hotel Peter and Paul.
Mother Superior
A home for contemplation or revelry, the Mother Superior does not judge. Both Mother Superior suites host a king canopy bed, adorned with tassels and holy finials. She is home to a serene bathroom with shower and bathtub and is decorated with an assortment of antique and bespoke furniture and lighting. She includes a flat-screen television, complimentary wifi, custom Italian linens, and air conditioning and toiletries made exclusively for Hotel Peter and Paul.
Like the classrooms and congregations before us, Hotel Peter & Paul has several areas that were designed with community and camaraderie in mind. In addition to several adjoining rooms that are perfect for families – there are four rooms tucked backstage behind the School House theater, five rooms above the Rectory parlors with plush and romantic finishings, and seven rooms meant for contemplation and respite in the Convent. Reach out to us at info@hotelpeterandpaul.com for more details about these rooms – we're here to help you along the way.
The Church
To inquire about reserving a room block,
please review the room types above,
then fill out the request form below.
Group Room Block Inquiry
To inquire about hosting a
private event of any type, visit our
Weddings page or use the below link
to fill out an inquiry.
Private Event Inquiry
.svg)